GENERAL HOSPITAL SPOILERS: WILL NINA REEVES BETRAY SONNY CORINTHOS OR DREW CAIN IN EXPLOSIVE PLEA DEAL?

TL;DR: Nina Reeves (Cynthia Watros) faces her biggest decision yet as her lawyer Marco Rios (Adrian Anchondo) approaches Acting D.A. Justine Turner (Nazneen Contractor) with a shocking plea bargain—offering damaging information on either mob boss Sonny Corinthos (Maurice Benard) or corrupt Congressman Drew Cain (Cameron Mathison) to save herself from prison after being arrested for Drew’s shooting.

THE ULTIMATE BETRAYAL IS COMING—AND PORT CHARLES WILL NEVER BE THE SAME

Just when you thought Nina Reeves couldn’t possibly make things WORSE for herself…

After getting arrested for the shooting of Congressman Drew Cain back in mid-October, Nina is officially in what the spoilers are calling “the hot seat.” And desperate times? They call for desperate measures. Her attorney Marco Rios is about to walk into Acting D.A. Justine Turner’s office and drop a bombshell that could reshape the entire power structure of Port Charles.

The leverage? Information that could take down either Sonny Corinthos—the man she used to love—or Drew Cain, the manipulative politician she had an affair with.

Talk about being stuck between a rock and a seriously hard place!

What Led to Nina Reeves’s Arrest on General Hospital?

Nina Reeves and her daughter Willow Tait were both arrested in mid-October for the attempted murder of Congressman Drew Cain after he was shot twice in his home back in early September.

The investigation was a classic Port Charles whodunnit—Drew’s recent descent into villain territory meant he had enemies EVERYWHERE. He’d been blackmailing Portia Robinson and Curtis Ashford, manipulating Willow, bribing judges, and generally making himself the most hated man in town. Detective Dante Falconeri and WSB agent Anna Devane had their hands full with suspects.

But when the PCPD found a gun at Elizabeth Webber’s home (where Willow had been staying), both mother and daughter found themselves in handcuffs. Current spoilers make it crystal clear that the prosecution is zeroing in on Nina as their main target, which is why Marco is scrambling to cut a deal.

Does Nina Have Real Leverage Against Sonny Corinthos?

Yes—and it’s EXTENSIVE.

As Sonny’s former wife and intimate partner, Nina has insider knowledge that prosecutors would kill for. We’re talking about the inner workings of his entire criminal organization, including how Corinthos Coffee functions as a front for money laundering. She knows about his key lieutenants like Brick and Jason Morgan. She could potentially testify about specific crimes, admissions she overheard, and the operational structure of his empire.

This is systemic intelligence spanning decades of criminal activity.

But here’s the catch—prosecuting Sonny would be a MASSIVE undertaking. He’s insulated by loyalty and legal expertise built over thirty years. Even with a cooperating witness, taking him down means a long, arduous legal battle. Is Justine Turner willing to gamble her career on that?

Could this mean the end of Sonny’s reign? It’s possible, but don’t count the mobster out just yet. This man has survived EVERYTHING Port Charles has thrown at him.

What Does Nina Know About Drew Cain?

Nina’s intelligence on Drew is fresher, more specific, and WAY easier to prove in court.

Unlike Sonny’s decades-old criminal empire, Drew’s crimes are recent and involve ordinary citizens who could be compelled to testify. Nina can provide direct testimony about:

The kicker? Nina has firsthand knowledge of his duplicitous character through their affair. She knows he was simultaneously involved with both her AND her daughter. That’s not just evidence—that’s a pattern of manipulation that establishes what kind of man he really is.

For a prosecutor looking for a clean, fast, high-profile conviction? Drew’s the easier target by a mile.

Will Nina Betray Sonny or Drew in the Plea Bargain?

Given Nina’s psychological profile and established motivations, she’ll most likely offer up Drew.

Here’s why this makes twisted sense: Nina’s entire character is driven by her obsession with her daughter Willow. Every major decision she makes somehow ties back to that desperate need for a maternal connection. (Remember the Nixon Falls deception? The SEC tip? The affair with Drew that cost Willow custody of her kids?)

In her mind, sacrificing Drew can be framed as a protective act—saving her daughter from a dangerous, manipulative predator. Never mind that it’s really about saving her OWN skin from prison! She gets to achieve self-preservation while wrapping it in the justification of maternal protection.

Plus—and let’s be real here—Nina is TERRIFIED of what Sonny would do if she betrayed him. The man hangs enemies on meat hooks. His code of loyalty is absolute. Even if she still has feelings for the “Mike” persona she fell in love with in Nixon Falls, survival instinct is a powerful motivator.

Don’t be surprised if Marco presents both options to Justine Turner, but Nina ultimately chooses the path of least resistance that also comes with the best rationalization for her conscience.

What’s the Sidwell Wild Card in Nina’s Plea Deal?

There’s a darker possibility lurking in the shadows—Marco Rios might not be working solely in Nina’s best interests.

Marco is the son of Jenz Sidwell, a rival mobster who would LOVE to see Sonny Corinthos taken down. This creates a massive conflict of interest that could change everything. What if Marco is subtly (or not so subtly) manipulating Nina into providing information on Sonny, not because it’s her best legal option, but because it serves his father’s mob war agenda?

If this theory plays out, Nina becomes an unwitting weapon in a power struggle she doesn’t even fully understand. And that would put her in EXTREME danger from Sonny’s organization—because betraying him, even unintentionally, is still betrayal in his world.

Could Marco be playing puppet master with Nina’s freedom? Given his family connections, it’s definitely something to watch.

What Happens Next for Nina, Sonny, and Drew?

However this plea negotiation shakes out, one thing is absolutely certain—Nina Reeves and Sonny Corinthos are DONE. Finished. Over.

In Sonny’s world, loyalty isn’t negotiable. The mere act of entering into a plea negotiation where his freedom is on the bargaining table? That’s the ultimate betrayal. It won’t matter if she ultimately targets Drew instead—the willingness to consider trading Sonny to save herself is unforgivable.

Through legal channels or underworld intelligence, Sonny WILL find out what happened in that interrogation room. And when he does? Nina transitions from complicated ex-lover to active enemy. Any hope of reconciliation—any lingering feelings from their Nixon Falls romance—gets incinerated in that moment.

If Nina successfully cuts a deal by providing evidence against Drew Cain, the fallout spreads even further. Willow is unlikely to see her mother’s actions as protective—she’ll view it as another selfish manipulation that brings MORE chaos into her life. The fragile maternal relationship Nina has sacrificed everything to build? Probably destroyed forever.

And a successful prosecution of Drew creates a significant power vacuum in Port Charles politics while potentially exposing his various victims and co-conspirators to legal jeopardy.

This isn’t just a plea bargain—it’s a CATALYST. The current power structure built around Sonny, Nina, Drew, and Carly is about to be shattered. New alliances will form. New enemies will emerge. The balance of power that’s defined Port Charles for so long? About to be fundamentally altered.

THE POINT OF NO RETURN

Reading between the lines of these spoilers, Nina Reeves is facing the biggest decision of her life—and there’s no good option. Betray the mob boss who values loyalty above all else? Or sacrifice the corrupt politician who manipulated her daughter?

Either way, she’s burning bridges she can never rebuild.

My prediction? She chooses Drew, wraps it in maternal protection, and walks out of that D.A.’s office legally free but completely isolated—estranged from Willow and now an enemy of the most powerful man in Port Charles.

But this is General Hospital, where nothing is ever simple and everyone has secrets. Don’t be shocked if Marco’s father pulls strings behind the scenes, Justine makes an unexpected move based on her complicated feelings for Sonny, or Nina makes an impulsive decision that surprises everyone (including herself).

What do YOU think Nina will do? Will she betray Sonny or Drew? And can she survive the fallout either way? The drama is just getting started!

Stay up to date with ongoing storylines with our General Hospital spoilers section.