IS MIKE HORTON STAYING IN SALEM WITH SON JEREMY? THE TRUTH ABOUT BOTH HORTON MEN REVEALED

TL;DR: Jeremy Horton is back on Days of Our Lives with a major recast and appears to be a permanent addition to the canvas, while his father Mike Horton’s confirmed return is only temporary for the show’s 60th anniversary celebration—despite what fans might be hoping for regarding this legendary Horton family reunion.

The Horton family is making headlines again, and longtime Days fans are buzzing with questions! The shocking return of Jeremy Horton—now recast with The Young and the Restless alum Michael Roark—has viewers wondering about the bigger picture. Is this just a brief visit, or is Salem getting a permanent new resident? And what about his famous father, Dr. Mike Horton? Will the man who once rode off into the sunset with Carrie Brady on a white horse be sticking around too?

The answers might surprise you. Because while one Horton is definitely here to stay, the other is just passing through.

Is Jeremy Horton Staying in Salem Long-Term?

Yes, Jeremy Horton is absolutely staying in Salem for the long haul. The evidence is crystal clear, and it all comes down to how soap operas handle casting decisions. When Days brought Jeremy back, they didn’t just call up the original actor for a quick cameo—they went out and hired Michael Roark, a recognizable face from Y&R who played Travis Crawford. That’s not a cheap or casual decision!

Soap operas operate on tight budgets and even tighter schedules. When they invest in recasting a character with a known daytime actor from another network, that’s a HUGE signal that they’re planning major storylines. And Jeremy’s not just wandering around Salem aimlessly—he’s been strategically positioned as a long-term substitute 5th-grade teacher at North Salem Elementary, where he’s teaching Thomas DiMera and Rachel Black. That puts him in daily contact with two of the show’s most powerful families!

His dramatic return on October 3rd wasn’t subtle either. Jeremy showed up unannounced on Stephanie Johnson‘s doorstep, leaving his ex-girlfriend completely shocked. The show revealed this bombshell three months in advance back in July, giving fans plenty of time to prepare for the drama ahead. That kind of advance planning? That’s not how you handle a temporary character—that’s how you build a long-term story arc.

Will Mike Horton Return Permanently With His Son?

No, Dr. Mike Horton is not returning to Salem permanently, and here’s how we know for certain. While it’s been officially confirmed that Roark Critchlow is reprising his beloved role as Mike, the context is everything. His return is specifically tied to Days’ massive 60th anniversary celebration happening in November 2025.

Mike is joining a whole parade of legacy characters coming back for this milestone event, including Sami Brady (Alison Sweeney), Jack Deveraux (Matthew Ashford), and Jennifer Horton (Melissa Reeves). Notice the pattern? These are all temporary, nostalgia-driven returns designed to honor the show’s incredible history—not to rebuild its future cast.

And Mike has done this before! He’s made brief guest appearances over the years, most recently showing up on October 4, 2022. His pattern has always been the same: come back for a special event, reconnect with family, then head back off-screen. There’s no indication this time will be any different.

The real tell? Compare how the show is handling father and son. Jeremy got added to the main contract cast list and received a major recast. Mike is listed under “returning cast” for a specific anniversary event. One is an investment in the future; the other is a celebration of the past.

What About Jeremy’s Dark and Abusive History?

Here’s where things get REALLY controversial. Jeremy Horton‘s last stint in Salem back in 2007 (when Trevor Donovan played the role) was absolutely horrifying. This wasn’t just a bad boy with a heart of gold—he was a violent criminal involved in DiMera smuggling operations and counterfeit schemes who emotionally and physically abused Stephanie Johnson.

The most infamous moment? Jeremy held Stephanie‘s head underwater in a hot tub during a rage-fueled attack. That’s not ancient history the writers can just sweep under the rug, and they’re not trying to. In fact, they’re weaponizing it as the central conflict of his return storyline!

Stephanie has published an erotic novel called “One Stormy Night” that’s based on her traumatic past relationship with Jeremy. So he’s returning to Salem at the exact moment her book is putting their history back in the spotlight. The timing is deliberate—the show is building a major story around trauma, abuse, and the question of whether someone can truly change.

Fans are understandably concerned. Social media is already buzzing with warnings that if Days tries to turn this into a romantic reconciliation, viewers will revolt. One fan bluntly stated online: “If he and Stephanie get together romantically, I’ll give up on this show.” The writers are walking a tightrope here, and they know it.

What’s Next for the Horton Family in Salem?

Mike Horton‘s November visit will likely involve reconnecting with his son and providing some fatherly guidance as Jeremy navigates his complicated return to Salem. Don’t be surprised if Mike offers wisdom about redemption and second chances—themes that have defined the Horton family for six decades. But once the anniversary celebrations wrap up, expect Mike to head back off-screen, leaving Jeremy to forge his own path.

As for Jeremy? His future is all about the explosive triangle developing between him, Stephanie Johnson, and her current partner Alex Kiriakis. This isn’t going to be a simple love story—it’s a psychological minefield. Can Stephanie trust the man who once terrorized her? Has Jeremy truly changed from the violent criminal who fled Salem in 2007? And how will Alex react when he learns the full truth about his girlfriend’s traumatic past?

The show is clearly investing in Jeremy as a long-term character, which could signal a bigger strategy to rebuild the depleted Horton family. Fans have been begging for years to see the Hortons and Bradys return to prominence after watching the DiMeras dominate Salem’s storylines. Bringing back a contract Horton male and building major plots around him might be the first step in a multi-year plan to restore this iconic family to the center of the canvas.

Could this mean Robin Jacobs (Jeremy’s mother) might eventually return too? Soap operas love bringing back the entire family unit when one character proves popular. Given Jeremy‘s complicated history, having his mother arrive to defend him—or confront him—would be classic Days drama!

One thing’s certain: the Horton legacy is being rebuilt one generation at a time. Mike Horton will provide the temporary link to the show’s glorious past, while Jeremy Horton carries the family name into Salem’s future—for better or worse.

Catch all the must-know Days of Our Lives spoilers and updates here.